The Culture Fit Myth

3 Min Read
Sara   |   January 22, 2019
WPLY_2201_Cultural Fit Featured Image

What is Cultural Fit?

Once an integral feature of most corporate recruitment processes, the term Cultural Fit was basically understood to mean someone who you’d be happy to go for a beer with. Highly subjective and completely arbitrary to whether someone is going to excel at the job or not, the act of hiring people based on whether we’d be happy to spend time with them outside of work is inherently flawed. Research proves that, unconscious or not, we’re all subject to bias and that our brains are wired towards pattern and similarity. When considering potential candidates, this means we’re statistically more likely to hire people like us which then breeds a homogenous culture and limits diversity of thought. “Not a cultural fit” became a blanket excuse for candidates that didn’t meet hiring managers’ preconceived idea of what the right person for the job should look like, sound like, even dress like. 

As companies have come to realise that greater diversity yields greater profitability, the more forward thinking enterprises are looking beyond previously utilised advertising channels to fill roles,  and re-thinking old-fashioned hiring criteria. 


The End of “Culture Fit”

Some of the world’s most successful and sought after companies to work for are putting greater emphasis on examining their internal teams and cultivating more diversity. The term “Culture Fit” is now banned at Facebook and interviewers are required to provide more specific feedback that supported their position. Interviews there were restructured to align with their 5 core values  and they even developed their own Managing Bias Training programme which is available to the public.

“At Facebook, we’ve explicitly asked interviewers not to use the term ‘culture fit’ when giving feedback on a candidate because that phrase can easily allow bias to influence the outcome of an interview. As part of a larger effort to help people identify and correct for the biases that we all inherently have, interviewers at Facebook go through managing bias training and are encouraged to use the skills they’ve learned when interviewing candidates.”

– Facebook Spokesperson

The Case for “Culture Add”


At Pandora, the term has evolved to “Culture Add” which has grown from an internal conversational term, into a formalised process embedded throughout the organisation. The notion of Culture Add reflects their Northern Star for Diversity which states that for them, “diversity is not a trend, it’s embedded in who we are and ingrained in everything we do. It’s reflected in our rich musical universe and that’s a direct result of people and their vibrant experiences.”


Culture fit or “Values Fit”

Another way to rethink the term Culture Fit for 2019 is as “Values Fit”. Australian Software and Project Management tool Atlassian has restructured their recruitment strategy to shift the focus upon candidates who will thrive in an environment with their company values, as the main priority. One of these values is about “Openness” - which, by publishing their diversity figures for all to see on their website, they are clearly committed to.

“Focusing on "values fit" ensures we hire people who share our sense of purpose and guiding principles, while actively looking for those with diverse viewpoints, backgrounds, and skill sets. We're trying to build a healthy and balanced culture, not a cult.”

- Aubrey Blanche, Global Head of Diversity & Inclusion

Building a diverse and inclusive culture rarely happens organically. In order to become an inclusive employer there needs to be deliberate effort and commitment from senior management in all departments. Introducing a “Blind Recruitment” process for full time hires is a big project, which won’t automatically eliminate unconscious bias, but will be a step in the right direction. To start experimenting with blind recruitment - try hiring a Weployee for a short term project or a temp role for a few days this week. With our One Day Guarantee - if it doesn’t work out, you have nothing to lose.


See how Weploy works for yourself
Related Articles
Featured, Ask the Experts
Blind Recruitment: The New Breed of CV

Whether we’re aware of it or not, the hiring process has inherent bias. It’s a neuroscientific fact that our brains are hardwired towards finding patterns and similarity - which we are now finding out is the worst thing possible when looking for talent.

Tips, Customer Service Insights
Seven Ways to Retain Top Performing Agents

The Australian Contact Centre Benchmark Report states that the average Full-Time customer service agent attrition rate in 2018 is at 19%. The impact of increasing attrition rates are affecting businesses more than ever, so it is important to ensure your team members feel valued, engaged and challenged. Here are a few actionable ways to help retain your team members and build a winning Employee Experience. 

Featured, Tips
How to Drive Culture in a Remote-First Environment

The impacts have been catastrophic, and the effects felt globally. A Gartner survey reveals 88% of organisations have encouraged or required employees to work from home due to Coronavirus, enforcing a global ‘Work from Home experiment’ which none of us saw coming and nobody had planned for. Surprisingly however, the experiment seems to have paid off. Studies have proven that most employees working remotely have not only adapted quickly to the new ways of working – but they have thrived too, reporting positive effects on their daily work, feeling more engaged, and having a stronger sense of well-being than those in non-remote jobs with little flexibility do. The post-COVID era is dawning, and now is the time to start planning for the Future Workplace.

Streamline your hiring

Business support staff with no hidden fees. Start hiring anytime.

Mask Group